A practical opening-by-opening comparison

MagnaTrack vs Accordion Shutters for Your Lanai

Short answer: lanais often have wide openings. MagnaTrack can span openings up to 30 ft × 24 ft per Progressive Screens; accordion shutters are the usual answer for house windows and doors.

(941) 356-3044

Free quotes within 48 hours.

Request a quote for MagnaTrack vs Accordion Shutters for Your Lanai

Free On-Site Estimate

Get Your Free Quote

Free quotes within 48 hours. No obligation.

Free on-site evaluation · Licensed & Insured · No obligation

The main distinction

Choose for the shape and use of the opening.

MagnaTrack retracts overhead to leave the view open when the screen is up. Accordion shutters are manually moved across an opening and are commonly used at house windows and doors. On a lanai, span, daily use and the exact storm-approved assembly all matter.

Side by side

How the systems compare

Comparison of MagnaTrack screens and accordion shutters for a lanai
ConsiderationMagnaTrackAccordion shutters
Opening sizeDesigned for wide openings; spans up to 30 ft × 24 ft per Progressive Screens.Typically suited to house windows and doors; very wide lanai openings are a poor fit.
View when openMotorized screen retracts overhead when not in use.Panels stack beside the opening when open.
Bugs and sunScreen fabric options can provide insect and sun protection for everyday use.Shutters close over the opening; they are not an everyday insect screen.
OperationMotorized operation; selected controls depend on the system.Manually operated.
Storm approvalFlorida Product Approved hurricane-rated options exist. Confirm the specific system and opening; not all fabric is storm-rated.A specific Florida Product Approved assembly must be confirmed for the opening.
Installed price range$50–$175 per sq ft installed.$15–$30 per sq ft installed.

Prices are planning ranges; the estimate depends on the measured opening and selected configuration.

Choose MagnaTrack for the lanai when…

The opening is wide, you want a screen for insects or sun in everyday use, and retracting it to restore the open view is important. Confirm any storm-protection option against the exact opening.

Choose accordion shutters for house openings when…

You are planning storm shutters for windows or doors and want a manually operated system that stays beside the opening when open. They are generally not the practical choice for a very wide lanai span.

Compare during the onsite estimate

An onsite estimate lets the team review the lanai dimensions, mounting conditions and nearby house openings together. That makes it easier to discuss a screen for the lanai and shutters where they fit the home.

Want the broader product comparison? Read the full guide.

From the gallery

Residential screen and balcony examples

Motorized retractable screens installed around a residential pool lanai
Residential balcony with wide motorized retractable screens

Common questions

Questions to consider

Accordion shutters are generally a poor fit for very wide lanai openings. MagnaTrack is designed for wide spans; the opening and selected system still need to be reviewed.

Plan around the opening you have.

Total Shutter Technologies, Inc. is a licensed general contractor (CGC1534742), serving Sarasota, Manatee and Charlotte Counties since 1999.

(941) 356-3044

Free quotes within 48 hours.